This seems to be very confusing to me. I always see people asking about witch hazel and how much they like it and how awesome it is. I am in this camp. I use Humphreys and Thayers and enjoy both. But the terminology is what kind of frustrates me.
The Latin term for witch hazel is Hamamelis Virginiana. By itself, it has a very unique smell. Some mention is rooty or bark like smell. It is a bit intense is you don't know what you are in for. Now Humphreys and Thayer's "Witch Hazel" contain many soothing and useful ingredients to tone or act as an astringent or help razor burn. These can include glycerin, aloe vera leaf juice, hydrosols as well as water and alcohol. But looking at the ingredient list, witch hazel is after many other ingredients and is not the main ingredient. My point is, witch hazel is far from the only thing in either of these products.
We don't speak about soap and refer to it as one of the ingredients. You don't call soap "lanolin" or "shea" just because it has it. You call it soap. I guess this is me getting my panties in a wad but would find my inner peace if people would start taking the ingredient list more seriously! Oh the humanity!![Biggrin Biggrin]()
Most of us are not using pure witch hazel. Many of us are enjoying formulated products which contain witch hazel. I will continue to use both of these products as they work for me and are very nice to use. But simply put, I couldn't go out and harvest some witch hazel, extract, and then get the same thing that comes from Thayers or Humphreys. It would take a lot of other additional ingredients to produce fine products like those.
Cheers!
The Latin term for witch hazel is Hamamelis Virginiana. By itself, it has a very unique smell. Some mention is rooty or bark like smell. It is a bit intense is you don't know what you are in for. Now Humphreys and Thayer's "Witch Hazel" contain many soothing and useful ingredients to tone or act as an astringent or help razor burn. These can include glycerin, aloe vera leaf juice, hydrosols as well as water and alcohol. But looking at the ingredient list, witch hazel is after many other ingredients and is not the main ingredient. My point is, witch hazel is far from the only thing in either of these products.
We don't speak about soap and refer to it as one of the ingredients. You don't call soap "lanolin" or "shea" just because it has it. You call it soap. I guess this is me getting my panties in a wad but would find my inner peace if people would start taking the ingredient list more seriously! Oh the humanity!

Most of us are not using pure witch hazel. Many of us are enjoying formulated products which contain witch hazel. I will continue to use both of these products as they work for me and are very nice to use. But simply put, I couldn't go out and harvest some witch hazel, extract, and then get the same thing that comes from Thayers or Humphreys. It would take a lot of other additional ingredients to produce fine products like those.
Cheers!